Skip to main content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( ) or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Taking Measure

Just a Standard Blog

How Measurement Science Helped Save Firefighting Planes

Andrew Slifka stands in the lab displaying a piece of wing flap with areas cut out.

Andrew Slifka shows pieces of a wing flap where he removed corroded areas for study.

Credit: Riley Wilson/NIST

As a resident of Colorado, I’ve watched wildfire-fighting planes fly overhead near my home and office. But I never thought much about them until I was asked to use my scientific analysis skills to help keep these planes from crashing. 

Even if you don’t live in a wildfire-prone area, you’ve probably seen photos of wildfire-fighting aircraft, known as air tankers. They fly over and around wildfires to drop specialized fire retardant to help firefighters on the ground contain the fire. 

The fire retardant must meet strict requirements to ensure that it doesn’t harm human, plant or animal health. When the U.S. Forest Service chooses a new retardant, experts test it in a lab before a few test flights. 

In 2023, representatives from NIST and the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) traveled to Montana and Oregon to check two air tankers that had begun showing signs of corrosion during routine inspections. The damage was so concerning that the NTSB immediately opened an investigation. We learned that if the problem wasn’t addressed, the planes could crash. In fact, it was good luck that they hadn’t crashed to date. 

NIST’s role was to analyze the corrosion's chemical composition to determine whether the fire retardant caused it. 

My former colleague, May Martin, and I brought pieces of several aircraft parts to our lab at NIST in Boulder, Colorado. We used a specialized tool called a scanning electron microscope to analyze the chemical makeup of the corroded areas. 

Andrew Slifka wears safety glasses and blue gloves as he stands in the lab opening a plastic bag holding part of an airplane wing.
Andrew Slifka shows part of a wing flap from a firefighting plane. The pink color comes from the residue of the fire retardant.
Credit: Riley Wilson/NIST

Previously, a phosphate-based retardant had been used in these firefighting planes. But during recent test flights, a magnesium chloride product was used. Our analysis showed the presence of chlorine in the aircraft parts. Lab testing later confirmed that even if only magnesium chloride was used, similar damage would occur. 

The magnesium chloride is no longer used. As far as I know, the corrosion issues have not returned. 

As a materials scientist and NIST researcher for nearly four decades, I found this to be one of the most interesting and meaningful projects of my career. We love our forests in Colorado, but they also bring fire risk. I was grateful to be a small part of the efforts to protect our forests. 

Additionally, it was a quick project — only a few months from start to finish. Most of my research takes years. This was an urgent problem that needed a fix as soon as we could provide the information requested. 

Finally, this was a role that only NIST could’ve played. The agencies involved in this project needed an entity with expertise but no preconceived notions or interest in the results. Our role was to make measurements and provide scientific analysis, and I’m grateful we had the opportunity to do that. 

Adapting to the National Needs 

My traditional research is not quite this dramatic. Over my many years at NIST, I’ve changed focus areas as the country’s needs have shifted. My research areas have ranged from the reliability of ceramic coatings for gas turbine aircraft engines to the properties of devices that diagnose high blood pressure in children’s lungs. 

The changing nature of my work means I never became the world’s leading expert in any area of science, as many of my NIST colleagues have done. But I have been adaptable and learned to apply lessons learned as my research areas have changed. It has also kept me interested and engaged for more than 40 years! 

The research I worked on the longest — about 15 years — was analyzing the effect of hydrogen on metals. Hydrogen is the most abundant element in the universe, and it’s also very tiny. So, it gets into everything, including metals, which can make metal crack more easily. My work involved helping engineers design structures that were both economical and less susceptible to hydrogen damage. 

Bolstering Lab Tests 

While I’m relieved we may have prevented a crash (and saved millions of dollars on replacement planes), Forest Service officials understandably want to prevent this from happening again. 

So, I’m working with them on an interagency collaboration to redesign the lab testing portion of the process — the first step I discussed earlier. It’s less dangerous and expensive to test these products in a lab on the ground. Ideally, we want the lab review to be so rigorous that there’s a very high likelihood that any product that passes this step will do well on test flights and pose no harm to the air tankers. 

Now that I’m in the final phase of my career and planning for retirement soon, I’m mostly focused on sharing my knowledge with the next generation of researchers in this field. 

This project has certainly given me a newfound appreciation for wildfire fighting. I will remember it when future wildfire-fighting air tankers fly by me in the skies over Colorado. 

About the author

Andrew Slifka

Andrew Slifka is a materials research engineer and has worked at NIST since 1991. Among Andrew’s research interests are mechanical measurements of structural steels in high-pressure hydrogen gas. Andrew earned his bachelor’s degree and Ph.D. from the Colorado School of Mines and his master’s degree from the University of Colorado.

Related Posts

Comments

Add new comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Please be respectful when posting comments. We will post all comments without editing as long as they are appropriate for a public, family friendly website, are on topic and do not contain profanity, personal attacks, misleading or false information/accusations or promote specific commercial products, services or organizations. Comments that violate our comment policy or include links to non-government organizations/web pages will not be posted.
Was this page helpful?