The effectiveness and the failure mechanism of fire barriers in residential upholstered furniture were investigated by full-scale flaming tests on upholstered chair mock-ups. Six commercial fire barriers were tested in this study. In the fire barriers, the presence of elements that are typically used in fire retardants were screened by several analytical methodologies; none of the targeted fire retardants were found by means of gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. For each fire barrier, triplicate flammability tests were run on chair mock-ups where polyurethane foam and polyester fiber fill were used as the padding materials, and each chair component was fully wrapped with the fire barrier of choice and a polypropylene cover fabric. The ignition source was an 18 kW square propane burner, impinging on the top surface of the seat cushion for 80 s. Results showed all six fire barriers reduced the peak heat release rate (as much as 64 %) and delayed its occurrence (up to 19 min) as compared to the control chair mock-ups. The heat release rate remained at a relatively low plateau level until liquid products (generated by either melting or pyrolysis of the padding material) percolated through the fire barrier at the bottom of the seat cushion and ignited, while the fire barrier was presumably intact. The flaming liquid products dripped and quickly formed a pool fire under the chair and the peak heat release rate occurred shortly thereafter. Ultimately, the ignition of the percolating liquid products at the bottom of the seat cushion was identified as the mechanism triggering the failure of the fire barrier.
Experiment Name | Plot of Heat Release Rate | Ignition Photo | Date/Time Sort descending | Specimen | Fuel Type | Test Duration (min) | Total Heat Released (MJ) | Peak HRR (kW) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Propane Burner Check | gas tube burner | Propane | 2.98
|
3.22
|
24.3
|
|||
B4-1 | upholstered chair mockup | Polyurethane Foam | 19.65
|
310
|
2,084
|
|||
C0-1 | upholstered chair mockup | Polyurethane Foam | 14.60
|
315
|
2,834
|
|||
B6-1 | upholstered chair mockup | Polyurethane Foam | 41.07
|
301
|
1,080
|
|||
B5-1 | upholstered chair mockup | Polyurethane Foam | 22.95
|
327
|
1,547
|
|||
B3-1 | upholstered chair mockup | Polyurethane Foam | 22.33
|
339
|
657
|
|||
B2-1 | upholstered chair mockup | Polyurethane Foam | 20.38
|
314
|
2,320
|
|||
B1-2 | upholstered chair mockup | Polyurethane Foam | 37.68
|
313
|
1,063
|
|||
C0-2 | upholstered chair mockup | Polyurethane Foam | 16.17
|
325
|
2,697
|
|||
Control-Smoldering | upholstered chair mockup | Polyurethane Foam | 40.28
|
below detection limit
|
9.4
|
|||
C0-3 | upholstered chair mockup | Polyurethane Foam | 19.43
|
321
|
2,517
|
Bryant, R. and Bundy, M. The NIST 20 MW Calorimetry Measurement System for Large-Fire Research, Technical Note (NIST TN) 2077, 2019
https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.TN.2077
NIST Fire Calorimetry Database (FCD)
https://doi.org/10.18434/mds2-2314