The capabilities of the NIST National Fire Research Laboratory (NFRL) will be extended to provide a test bed for performance evaluation of instruments and test methods used for the monitoring of greenhouse gas emissions from point sources at close to industrial scale. In addition, atmospheric dispersion models will be assessed and developed to design optimal placement of sensor systems and to provide realistic and substantial uncertainty estimates of greenhouse gas emissions from area sources based on sensor field measurements.
Objective: By 2015, create a well-characterized highly accurate reference measurement system at near industrial scale to serve as a test bed for carbon dioxide gas emissions, and to improve and evaluate atmospheric dispersion models for reducing model uncertainties in greenhouse gas source prediction.
What is the new technical idea? The new technical idea is to use measurement science and state-of-the-art CFD modeling to characterize greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and transport, in order to create sound scientific data that can be used to better understand the performance of green buildings and communities. Two project tasks are emphasized:
The first task is to use the National Fire Research Laboratory’s (NFRL) exhaust duct and stack as a surrogate for a close to full scale industrial facility or small power plant (10 MW). Precise measurement of CO2 emission rates from the NFRL will allow it to serve as a test bed for point source measurements. Reduced uncertainties will be achieved by employing a well-controlled and well-characterized combustion source of CO2 and through systematically improving the component measurements. The CO2 emissions test bed will be used to evaluate current stack-mounted test methods and continuous emission monitoring systems (CEMS) as well as new technologies for open-path remote sensing and stack-mounted measurement systems.
For the second task, we propose to reduce the uncertainty associated with predicting emissions from area source inventories of greenhouse gases. Industry currently estimates greenhouse gas emissions based on the raw materials that go into factories or power plants (a so called “bottom-up” calculation). Countries tabulate these estimates to report nationwide figures of greenhouse gas inventories. These emission inventories are used in models to estimate the atmospheric chemical composition. However, there are large uncertainties in bottom-up estimates. Atmospheric measurements suggest that GHG emission can be double of those based on bottom-up calculations,. The new technical idea is to use atmospheric concentration measurements and inversion methods as part of a top-down calculation to evaluate and improve existing emission inventories. Development and validation of the inversion models will provide an estimate of model uncertainty and will form the scientific basis for verification and monitoring of greenhouse gas emissions. Strong collaboration with academia, industry, and national research laboratories as well as the availability of validated software tools and computer resources will ensure that results are achieved in a timely fashion.
What is the research plan? The research plan consists of two major components, a) reduction of the measurement uncertainty for point source emissions, and b) reduction of the uncertainty associated with the use of atmospheric dispersion models used with inversion modeling techniques.
We will extend the capabilities of the NFRL to provide an emissions test bed, at near industrial-scale, for the performance evaluation of instruments of the type generally used for CEMS and relative accuracy testing audits (RATA). Measurement improvements include better calibration gas standards, independent flow measurements for cross validation, optimization of probe locations using detailed mapping experiments, and more accurate calibrations for flow and gas measurement probes and transducers. The test bed will be used for the development of an accreditation program for independent, private sector measurement providers, and for test protocol development assisting documentary standard efforts. Ultimately, these new measurements and standards capabilities will lead to improvements in determination of greenhouse gas emission inventories.
The focus of the modeling work will be on predicting CO2 and CH4 emissions from area source inventories by using atmospheric mixing ratio observations and wind field estimates in an inversion framework. Gaussian plume equations will be combined within an inversion framework to provide a simple, inexpensive and an easy-to-use tool for estimating uncertainty and sensitivity to model parameters. Inversion models will also be coupled with computational fluid dynamics (CFD) software tools such as Fire Dynamics Simulator (FDS) and Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF). These methods will have the capability to account for complex urban topography, but are also expected to be computationally intensive. Backward Lagrangian Stochastic (bLS) simulations coupled with various atmospheric dispersion models will allow prediction of source strength and location from complex shaped sources. The test bed for modeling will be Los Angeles and Indianapolis, as plans are underway for carrying out field tests of greenhouse gas dispersion by the INFLUX project. Since the model domain includes a large city, much of the flow is over an urban topography. Using FDS, NIST will investigate the effects of the urban canopy at horizontal resolutions of 10-20 m and test the efficacy of the method through comparison of model results with well-known field experiments (Prairie Grass and Kit Fox). This involves the modification and validation of new turbulent inlet and stochastic particle models in FDS. Simulations will be performed to evaluate optimal location of sensors in an effort to maximize the emission signatures. These simulations will guide the strategic deployment of sensors in Los Angeles and provide accurate estimates of greenhouse gas emissions.
 Nisbet, E., and Weiss, R. 2010 Top-down versus bottom-up. Science 328:1241-1243
 Verifying Greenhouse Gas Emissions: Methods to Support International Climate Agreements, National Research Council of the National Academies, The National Academic Press, Washington DC, 2010.
 Aircraft-Based Measurements of the Carbon Footprint of Indianapolis, K. L. Mays, P. B. Shepson, B. H. Stirm, A. Karion, C. Sweeney, and K. R. Gurney, Environ. Sci. Technol. 2009, 43, 7816-7823
The CO2 emissions measurement capabilities of the NFRL will provide a test bed to evaluate the test methods (ASTM D3154, ISO TC 146/SC 1) and regulatory standards (EPA 40 CFR Part 60 and 75) associated with monitoring point-source emissions. The current strategy is to collaborate with the electric power industry, source testing companies, and EPA to design evaluation criteria for the test bed and develop a research agenda that addresses the appropriate technical challenges. Industry stakeholders include the Electric Power Research Institute and the Source Evaluation Society. Regulatory stakeholders include the EPA and state government environmental authorities. Work with these groups will ensure that the NFRL measurements will be the basis for generating defendable uncertainty estimates and improving the next cycle of standards. The anticipated impact of both efforts, point source measurements and dispersion modeling, is better agreement between the top-down and bottom-up greenhouse gas accounting through improved measurement science.
Colimore Thoemke Architects
Start Date:October 1, 2011
Lead Organizational Unit:el
Related Programs and Projects:
100 Bureau Drive, M/S 8664