NIST/University of Colorado Scientists Create New Form of Matter: A Fermionic Condensate
For Immediate Release: January 28, 2004
Scientists at JILA, a joint laboratory of the Department of Commerce’s National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and the University of Colorado at Boulder (CU-Boulder) report the first observation of a “fermionic condensate” formed from pairs of atoms in a gas, a long-sought, novel form of matter. Physicists hope that further research with such condensates eventually will help unlock the mysteries of high-temperature superconductivity, a phenomenon with the potential to improve energy efficiency dramatically across a broad range of applications.
The research is described in a paper to be published in the Jan. 24-30 online edition of Physical Review Letters by JILA authors Deborah S. Jin, a physicist at NIST and an adjoint associate professor at CU-Boulder, and Markus Greiner and Cindy Regal, a post-doctoral researcher and graduate student at CU-Boulder.
“The strength of pairing in our fermionic condensate, adjusted for mass and density,” Jin explains, “would correspond to a room temperature superconductor. This makes me optimistic that the fundamental physics we learn through fermionic condensates will eventually help others design more practical superconducting materials.”
The new work complements a previous major achievement, creation of a “Bose-Einstein” condensate, which earned JILA scientists Eric Cornell and Carl Wieman, the Nobel Prize in Physics in 2001. Bose-Einstein condensates are collections of thousands of ultracold particles occupying a single quantum state, that is, all the atoms are behaving identically like a single, huge superatom. Bose-Einstein condensates are made with bosons, a class of particles that are inherently gregarious; they’d rather adopt their neighbor’s motion than go it alone.
Unlike bosons, fermions—the other half of the particle family tree and the basic building blocks of matter—are inherently loners. By definition, no fermion can be in exactly the same state as another fermion. Consequently, to a physicist even the term—fermionic condensate—is almost an oxymoron.
For many decades, physicists have proposed that superconductivity (which involves fermions) and Bose-Einstein condensates (BEC) are closely linked. Theorists have hypothesized that superconductivity and BEC are two extremes of superfluid behavior, an unusual state where matter shows no resistance to flow. Superfluid liquid helium, for example, when poured into the center of an open container, will spontaneously flow up and over the sides of the container.
In the current experiment, a gas of 500,000 potassium atoms was cooled to temperatures below 50 billionths of a degree Celsius above absolute zero (minus 459 degrees Fahrenheit) and then a magnetic field was applied near a special “resonance” strength. This magnetic field coaxed the fermion atoms to match up into pairs, akin to the pairs of electrons that produce superconductivity, the phenomenon in which electricity flows with no resistance. The Jin group detected this pairing and the formation of a fermionic condensate for the first time on Dec. 16, 2003.
The temperature at which metals or alloys become superconductors depends on the strength of the “pairing” interaction between their electrons. The highest known temperature at which superconductivity occurs in any material is about minus 135 degrees Celsius (minus 216 degrees Fahrenheit).
Funding for the research was provided by NIST, the National Science Foundation, and the Hertz Foundation of Livermore, Calif.
In October 2003, Jin, 35, received a $500,000 John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Fellowship, often referred to as a “genius grant.”
As a non-regulatory agency of the U.S. Department of Commerce’s Technology Administration, NIST develops and promotes measurement, standards and technology to enhance productivity, facilitate trade and improve the quality of life.
The University of Colorado at Boulder is a comprehensive research institution located in the foothills of the Rocky Mountains and has an enrollment of 29,151 students. CU-Boulder was founded in 1876 and is known for its strong programs in the natural sciences, space sciences, environmental sciences, education, music and law. It received a record $250 million in sponsored research funding last fiscal year.
Background: History and Research Details
In 2001 JILA researcher Murray Holland and co-workers predicted that fermionic atom condensates would turn out to be the link between superconductivity and BECs. Holland’s group suggested that magnetic fields could be used to “tune” a gas of atoms to create a “resonance condensate” between superconductivity and BEC behaviors.
The experiments conducted by Jin’s team appear to confirm these predictions. “We expect that the fermionic condensates that we observed,” notes Jin, “will exhibit superfluid behavior. They represent a novel phase that lies in the crossover between superconductors and BEC.”
In November 2003, Jin’s team (as well as a separate research group in Innsbruck, Austria) reported producing a Bose-Einstein condensate of molecules. In those experiments, a time-varying magnetic field was applied to fermionic atoms that forced them to combine into bosonic molecules. Fermions have half-integer “spins” (1/2, 3/2, 5/2, etc.), while bosons have integer “spins” (1, 2, 3, etc.). Spins are additive, so that a molecule containing two fermionic atoms is a boson. However, even if two fermions are not bound into one molecule, but merely move together in a correlated fashion, then as a pair they can act like a boson, and undergo condensation. It is this second, more subtle form of condensation that has been observed in the current experiments.
The current work was performed by applying a particular magnetic field at values where individual fermionic atoms cannot bind together to form bosonic molecules. Instead, pairing of fermions is caused by the collective behavior of many atoms, similar to what causes “Cooper pairs” of electrons to form in a superconductor.
Paradoxically, n order to detect that the experiment produced a condensate from paired fermions (and not molecules), the researchers had to first convert the pairs into molecules. A magnetic field at the right strength for molecular bonding was rapidly applied to the fermionic condensate and simultaneously the optical “trap” holding the gas was opened. This magnetic field change can create molecules, but was too fast to create a molecular BEC, as previously shown. Nonetheless, a “picture” of the molecules’ motion showed the characteristic shape of a condensate cloud. (See figure 1.)
“It happens too fast for anything to move around,” says Jin. “The condensate that appears in our ‘snapshot’ of the gas has to have existed before the molecules were formed.”
In simple terms, the fermion pairs are like high-schoolers at a dance. When the band plays fast music, many dancers pair up and move together in a coordinated way (Figure 2). If the band suddenly switches to a slow dance, the dancers in each pair move closer and “bond” (Figure 3). If a flash photograph is then taken immediately, the ‘snapshot’ will show “bound” dancers (molecules), but the arrangement of those dancers was determined earlier when the pairs first matched up.
“Even in this first observation we were able to see the fermionic atom condensates in a much more direct way than anyone had anticipated,” says Jin. “This opens up the very exciting potential to study superconductivity and superfluid phenomena under extreme conditions that have never existed before.”